Comments on: App Review: Go Go Go! – GPXL’s Guide to F1™ 2009 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/ Original comment and commentary, with a UK focus. Not another cut 'n' paste news site. Wed, 01 Feb 2012 03:43:00 +0000 hourly 1 By: Matt Radford http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3624 Matt Radford Tue, 24 Mar 2009 23:41:40 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3624 Keep it civil please Andrew. Andy has some experience with F1 and has picked up both good and bad points to this app; overall it's a considered piece. I'm not interested in posting unjustified diatribes on the site, but where a reviewer has legitimate concerns about an application, I welcome their views. Keep it civil please Andrew.

Andy has some experience with F1 and has picked up both good and bad points to this app; overall it’s a considered piece. I’m not interested in posting unjustified diatribes on the site, but where a reviewer has legitimate concerns about an application, I welcome their views.

]]> By: Iain 117 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3620 Iain 117 Tue, 24 Mar 2009 18:06:54 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3620 Once, twice, three times a goodun' My bad :-D Once, twice, three times a goodun’

My bad :-D

]]> By: Iain 117 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3619 Iain 117 Tue, 24 Mar 2009 18:05:58 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3619 I think that's how you spell "owned" Andy ;-) Good review too. I think that’s how you spell “owned” Andy ;-)

Good review too.

]]> By: Iain 117 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3618 Iain 117 Tue, 24 Mar 2009 18:05:38 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3618 I think that's how you spell "owned" Andy ;-) I think that’s how you spell “owned” Andy ;-)

]]> By: Andy Cook http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3616 Andy Cook Tue, 24 Mar 2009 16:09:14 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3616 Hi Andrew, Thanks for specifying your objections - difficult to respond otherwise. I did mention the problems in the data that I spotted, including spelling mistakes. To my mind, a reviewer has an obligation to point out the problems found as well as the plus points. When it's a review of an app whose purpose is, at least partially, as a reference, then mistakes in the information are all the more important and should certainly be reported. If the spelling mistakes don't concern you, then of course you are free to ignore them but it's the job of a reviewer to report them, giving the reader that choice. The mention of the spelling mistakes took up one sentence of the review ("Veteran driver Rubens Barrichello’s name is listed on one screen as ‘Barruchello’ and ‘Barrichelo’ on another"). I wouldn't say that constitutes 'waffling on' but perhaps your definition differs from mine :) I do say at the end that I’d be reluctant to recommend this app even if it was free. I'm not sure how this makes me a cheapskate though. If I was a cheapskate, then surely I’d be more likely to recommend it if it was free, wouldn’t I? Whether or not I am a cheapskate, does that negate the problems I found in the app? Again, I'm sorry if you felt my review didn't give you the information you needed to decide whether this app would be of interest to you. Andy. Hi Andrew,

Thanks for specifying your objections – difficult to respond otherwise.

I did mention the problems in the data that I spotted, including spelling mistakes. To my mind, a reviewer has an obligation to point out the problems found as well as the plus points. When it’s a review of an app whose purpose is, at least partially, as a reference, then mistakes in the information are all the more important and should certainly be reported. If the spelling mistakes don’t concern you, then of course you are free to ignore them but it’s the job of a reviewer to report them, giving the reader that choice.

The mention of the spelling mistakes took up one sentence of the review (“Veteran driver Rubens Barrichello’s name is listed on one screen as ‘Barruchello’ and ‘Barrichelo’ on another”). I wouldn’t say that constitutes ‘waffling on’ but perhaps your definition differs from mine :)

I do say at the end that I’d be reluctant to recommend this app even if it was free. I’m not sure how this makes me a cheapskate though. If I was a cheapskate, then surely I’d be more likely to recommend it if it was free, wouldn’t I? Whether or not I am a cheapskate, does that negate the problems I found in the app?

Again, I’m sorry if you felt my review didn’t give you the information you needed to decide whether this app would be of interest to you.

Andy.

]]> By: Andrew http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3613 Andrew Tue, 24 Mar 2009 12:31:28 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3613 Usefull? He waffles on about spelling mistakes (big deal) - and then tells you he wouldn't even recommend it if was FREE !! Hahaha, talk about cheapskate! Would you also like the moon on a stick free of charge? Usefull?

He waffles on about spelling mistakes (big deal) – and then tells you he wouldn’t even recommend it if was FREE !!

Hahaha, talk about cheapskate! Would you also like the moon on a stick free of charge?

]]> By: Bryn Thomas http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3603 Bryn Thomas Mon, 23 Mar 2009 19:12:39 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3603 I think this was a useful review Andy. Good to know a bit about the reviewers background too, so one has a feel of what you're looking for in the app. I wouldn't listen to the critics here, too often people review products from the developers perspective and end up waving away the flaws with some weak "well if you like F1 statistics you'll like this app", rather than using it as a regular person with an interest in F1 would. I think this was a useful review Andy. Good to know a bit about the reviewers background too, so one has a feel of what you’re looking for in the app. I wouldn’t listen to the critics here, too often people review products from the developers perspective and end up waving away the flaws with some weak “well if you like F1 statistics you’ll like this app”, rather than using it as a regular person with an interest in F1 would.

]]> By: Andrew http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3599 Andrew Mon, 23 Mar 2009 14:36:35 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3599 what it said was "i'm a self important idiot with nothing better to do" what it said was “i’m a self important idiot with nothing better to do”

]]> By: Andy Cook http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3595 Andy Cook Mon, 23 Mar 2009 12:07:00 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3595 Sorry if it wasn't useful to you. I was hoping it said something about my point of view - rather important to get the most from the review, I think. After using the app quite extensively, I believe I gave an objective overview of it. I'd be interested to hear what you think I said that was inaccurate or unfair. Sorry if it wasn’t useful to you.

I was hoping it said something about my point of view – rather important to get the most from the review, I think.

After using the app quite extensively, I believe I gave an objective overview of it. I’d be interested to hear what you think I said that was inaccurate or unfair.

]]> By: Andrew http://www.allaboutiphone.net/2009/03/app-review-go-go-go-%e2%80%93-gpxl%e2%80%99s-guide-to-f1%e2%84%a2-2009/#comment-3594 Andrew Mon, 23 Mar 2009 11:28:34 +0000 http://www.allaboutiphone.net/?p=1443#comment-3594 What is the point of these new reviews? The first 4 paragraphs are all about yourself - that really says something.... What is the point of these new reviews? The first 4 paragraphs are all about yourself – that really says something….

]]>